Provocative opinion from a third sector maverick

Don't leave young people holding the baby

For the last twenty years we have had dynasties in the White House.  The Clinton and the Bush families have occupied the number one slot and demonstrated the support network that brings to great, if opportunistic (or some may say exploitative), effect.   Not much disaffected young people can relate to.  If your family is divided or divisive, their expectations of you are low and you fight your battles yourself then identifying with Chelsea Clinton nestling up to her mother on a stadium stage is going to be tricky.   This is what the pollsters are hoping is going to attract first-time votes to Obama, that he has had it as hard as they have and they can identify with him.  He has just used his children for the first time, to show what a united family they are and to allow his wife to soften her image by demonstrating what a good little wifey she is.   Something about this made me feel slightly uneasy, especially on a day when we discover that Bristol Palin, the seventeen year old unmarried pregnant daughter of Republican McCain's Christian running mate, is "keeping the baby and marrying the father", (can't imagine there was much choice about that). 

Young people need to be engaged in politics but parading "happy and normal" families in front of them is not the way to do it.

Comments

 

Mike Amos-Simpson said:

I don't think a divided family necessarily has low expectations for its children (depending on what you mean by 'low') - very often I think they hope for better for their children.

I don't think theres anything wrong with 'parading' happy & normal families other than whether you yourself decide to bias your opinions about potential candidates on that basis (if so the issue lies with you). But I do think theres nothing wrong with 'happy & normal' as an aspiration and therefore its fine to promote it. As for the young girl keeping the baby and marrying the father isn't that a dilemma that faces a great deal of young people who find themselves in similar situations?

September 7, 2008 2:11 AM

Children & Young People Now is the official publication for members of the National Children's Bureau and The National Youth Agency.